Five Top Reasons Mediation Fails
May 9, 2023

Mediation is a popular alternative to traditional litigation, allowing parties to resolve disputes in a non-adversarial, cost-effective, and confidential manner. However, like any other process, mediation can sometimes fail. In this blog post, we will discuss the top reasons why mediation can fail and offer solutions to prevent it.


Lack of Preparation: One of the main reasons why mediation can fail is a lack of preparation. Parties may come to mediation unprepared, without a clear understanding of their needs and interests, or without the necessary documentation to support their positions. The solution is to ensure that parties are well-prepared and have all the information they need to make informed decisions. Mediators can provide parties with a checklist of documents and information needed, as well as offer guidance on how to prepare for mediation.


Unrealistic Expectations: Another common reason why mediation can fail is unrealistic expectations. Parties may come to mediation expecting a complete resolution of all their issues or a one-sided outcome. The solution is to manage expectations and help parties understand that mediation is a collaborative process that requires compromise and negotiation. Mediators can help parties set realistic goals and expectations for the mediation process.


Lack of Trust: A lack of trust between parties can also cause mediation to fail. Parties may be unwilling to share information or may be suspicious of the other party's motives. The solution is to build trust and rapport between parties. Mediators can help parties establish a relationship of trust and respect by setting ground rules for communication, ensuring that both parties have an opportunity to speak, and using active listening and empathic communication.


Failure to Communicate: Effective communication is essential to the success of mediation. If parties are unable to communicate effectively, mediation may fail. The solution is to ensure that parties have the necessary communication skills to participate in mediation. Mediators can provide guidance on effective communication techniques, such as active listening, reframing, and summarizing.


Inflexibility: Finally, inflexibility can also cause mediation to fail. Parties may be unwilling to consider alternative solutions or may be stuck in a rigid position. The solution is to encourage flexibility and creativity. Mediators can help parties brainstorm creative solutions and evaluate the pros and cons of each option. Mediators can also suggest compromises that may not have been considered before.


By addressing these issues and working collaboratively, parties can increase the likelihood of success in mediation. If you are considering mediation as a way to resolve a dispute, be sure to choose a skilled and experienced mediator who can help you navigate the process effectively.


This blog post was written by Chelle Hendershot, Registered Mediator, Hope For Our Future, LLC. This blog is not intended to be legal advice or a solicitation for services. It is an advertisement.


Copyright © 2023 Hope For Our Future, LLC. All rights reserved. This blog post may be shared, copied, and distributed in its entirety for non-commercial purposes, provided that proper attribution is given, and no modifications are made to the original work.

Related Post

Creative Ways to Bond With Your Kids After Divorce

June 24, 2025
Divorce changes many things—but it doesn’t have to damage the connection you have with your children. In fact, this can be a time to build even stronger bonds as you adjust to your new life together. Whether you have primary custody, shared parenting time, or just a few days each month, there are meaningful ways to make the most of your time and show up in your child’s life in a way that counts. Here are some creative, low-pressure ways to strengthen your relationship with your child after a divorce—no expensive trips or grand gestures required. 1. Create New Traditions Together Your family might not look the same as it used to, but you can still create memories that are uniquely yours. Try: A Friday night pizza-and-movie tradition Sunday morning breakfast runs A “Yes Day” once a month where the child plans the day (within reason) A monthly family photo walk to document your time together Kids thrive on consistency, so these new routines give them something to look forward to and help rebuild a sense of security. 2. Write Notes or Leave Messages Sometimes it’s hard for kids to talk about their feelings out loud, especially during or after a family split. Small notes in their backpack, lunchbox, or pillow (“I’m proud of you,” “I love you no matter what”) help keep the connection strong. If you live apart or only see them on weekends, consider: Leaving a short video message Mailing a postcard or drawing Creating a shared journal to pass back and forth This is especially helpful for younger children or kids who aren’t ready to talk openly yet. 3. Involve Them in Everyday Life Not every visit has to be an event. Kids often feel more connected when they’re simply included in your day-to-day activities. Let them: Help cook dinner Pick out groceries Assist with a house project or organizing task Come along for errands and car rides These everyday moments can be just as powerful as special outings. You’re not only bonding—you’re teaching life skills and building trust. 4. Let Them Teach You Something Kids love when adults take an interest in their world. Ask them to teach you: Their favorite video game A TikTok dance How to use a new app or feature A fun skill they learned in school Letting them be the expert builds confidence and shows that you value their opinions. It also gives you insight into what lights them up. 5. Do a Parent-Child Challenge Together Friendly competition is a fun way to bond! Try: A 30-day drawing challenge A reading race (who can finish more pages?) A step-count contest using a phone or watch Learning a new skill together (like origami, card tricks, or juggling) You don’t have to be good at it. The key is doing it together and cheering each other on. 6. Make Transitions Easier With Rituals Going from one house to the other can be tough for kids. Try a “transition ritual” to smooth the handoff: Listen to a favorite song on the way to or from visits Pack a special bag or comfort item they take between homes Read the same short story when they arrive Plan a small treat or snack to mark the change These habits signal safety and consistency and make the transition feel more predictable and less emotionally jarring. 7. Keep the Focus on Them—Not the Past You may be dealing with unresolved feelings from your relationship with the other parent. But this time is about your child—not the divorce, not court orders, and not your ex. Avoid talking negatively about the other parent. Instead, use your time to really see your child: what they’re into, how they’re growing, what they’re feeling, and who they’re becoming. Final Thoughts Rebuilding and deepening your relationship with your child after a divorce takes time, patience, and presence—but it’s absolutely possible. Children don’t need perfection. They need consistency, attention, and love. Start small. Choose one idea. Build from there. If you’re struggling to figure out how to make the most of your parenting time or need help navigating conflict with the other parent, services like mediation or parenting coordination can help. Sometimes a little guidance can go a long way toward strengthening your family’s future—one connection at a time. Photo Credit: 94464454 Syda Productions Dreamstime.com

Why Paternity Matters for Custody and Parenting Time in Indiana

June 16, 2025
In Indiana, establishing paternity isn’t just a legal formality—it’s the foundation for a father’s rights and responsibilities when it comes to child custody and parenting time. Whether you're a father seeking more time with your child or a mother wanting to ensure support and involvement, understanding the role of paternity is key to protecting the child's best interests. This post explains what paternity means, how it’s established, and why it matters so much in family law cases involving custody, parenting time, and child support. What Is Paternity? Paternity is the legal recognition of a man as a child’s father. In Indiana, if parents are married when a child is born, the husband is presumed to be the legal father. But if parents are unmarried, the father must take additional steps to establish paternity—even if he is already involved in the child's life. Without legal paternity, a father has no enforceable rights to parenting time or decision-making—even if he is biologically related to the child. How to Establish Paternity in Indiana There are two main ways to establish paternity if the parents are not married: Paternity Affidavit This form can be signed at the hospital when the child is born or later at the local health department. It must be signed by both parents and filed with the Indiana State Department of Health. This gives the father legal rights, but does not automatically create a parenting time or custody order. 2. Court Order Either parent may file a paternity action in court. If there is a dispute, the court may order DNA testing. Once paternity is established by court order, the court can also enter orders regarding custody, parenting time, and child support. Why Paternity Matters for Fathers Without establishing paternity, a father cannot: Request custody or parenting time through the court Make legal decisions for the child (like education or health care) Have the court protect his parenting rights Establishing paternity is the first step to creating a parenting plan, having shared responsibilities, and building a legally recognized relationship with your child. Why Paternity Matters for Mothers and Children For mothers, establishing paternity is essential for: Seeking child support Ensuring the child has access to both parents' medical histories Allowing the child to qualify for certain benefits through the father (like Social Security, inheritance, or veteran’s benefits) And for children, legal paternity gives them a clearer identity, financial security, and—perhaps most importantly—the right to have a relationship with both parents if it is safe and appropriate to do so. What Happens After Paternity Is Established? Once paternity is confirmed, either parent can request a court order for: Custody – The court decides who will make major decisions for the child and where the child will primarily live. Parenting Time – The non-custodial parent (or sometimes both) can receive a parenting schedule, often following Indiana’s Parenting Time Guidelines. Child Support – Based on income and parenting time, the court may order financial support. Establishing paternity opens the door to these discussions and provides a legal framework for moving forward. How Mediation Can Help Mediation offers a respectful, non-adversarial space to work out parenting agreements after paternity is established. A mediator can help both parents: Develop a parenting time schedule Create a custody arrangement that works for the child Resolve conflict in a child-centered way At Hope For Our Future, LLC, we regularly help parents navigate these conversations without heading straight into courtroom battles. Final Thoughts Paternity is more than paperwork—it’s the legal and emotional foundation of a child’s right to be loved and supported by both parents. Whether you’re a father seeking involvement or a mother wanting to clarify legal rights and responsibilities, taking steps to establish paternity is a powerful first move toward healthy co-parenting.  If you need support with mediation, parenting coordination, or understanding your options after paternity is established, we’re here to help. This post was written by Chelle Hendershot, who is a dedicated Mediator, Guardian ad Litem, and Parenting Coordinator at Hope For Our Future, LLC, with a passion for helping individuals and families navigate through life's most challenging moments. This post is not intended to be legal advice and is for marketing purposes only. Photo Credit: 7182409 Partnerinflight Dreamstime.com